Film review: I Am Not Your Negro
by Stephen Hewitt | Published 10 April 2017 | Last updated 11 December 2020
On around 9pm the Cambridge Arts Picturehouse showed the film ‘I am not your Negro’, directed by Raoul Peck, to an almost empty auditorium.
At the start of this film, I knew nothing about Baldwin and very little about this particular chapter of the murderous history of the USA. By the end, 95 minutes later, the increase in what I knew on these subjects was not much, but it was enough to be sure that James Baldwin was a lot more intelligent than this film, which would be more accurately described as patronising persuasion than informative documentary.
This is a film with no narration that informs or explains - all the narrated words are (presumably) Baldwin's. At least, there is consistently a first person in the narration that is, or is pretending to be, Baldwin. The film is careful not to explain this but what looked like a long list of Baldwin's writings appeared in the credits.
It consists essentially of archive footage and the narration. There is no new document, no interviews, no evidence of research. It seems unlikely that this so-called documentary inserted a single new fact into the public record.
The more memorable parts of the film are footage of Baldwin speaking, for example in talk shows on television and addressing a packed Cambridge Union in 1965, for which he received a standing ovation.
There is also a first hand description of a meeting which included Bobby Kennedy, at the time USA Attorney General, and a woman who requested of him that his brother JFK, the president of the USA, would walk with a black girl into a school. This was refused, and Baldwin (presumably) wrote that Bobby Kennedy seemed to think we were wasting his time.
Towards the end, it abandons all pretence of documentary and slides towards patronising propaganda, although without a clear agenda. In an especially nauseating sequence, the film arranges a gratuitous line of non whites in front of the camera, like animals in a zoo, for the viewing pleasure of the audience.
In the credits, the European Union is listed as one of the funders of the film.
- Rosi on filming real-life confessions of a drug hitman in Mexican police 21 May 2017, Cambridge Arts Picturehouse, Regent Street
- Hora Chilena, a film about Cambridge life of refugees from 1973 coup in Chile 20 Oct 2014 screening and discussion in Cambridge
- UCL Prof John Dickie talk, questions and film, promoting ‘Mafia Republic’ 13 May 2013, Cambridge
- Film Review: 'Hidden Wars of Desert Storm' A film produced by Gerard Ungerman & Audrey Brohy, 2000
- Film review: Dreams of Sparrows (Iraq, 2006) 10 July 2006 shown in Cambridge, director Hayad Daffar